Why You Should Think Twice Before Using Reedsy Discovery

Reedsy Discovery: A Cautionary Tale for Self-Published Authors

Are you a self-published author seeking feedback on your manuscript? Before you dive into platforms like Reedsy Discovery, consider my experience. I waited months for a review that felt rushed, dismissive, and ultimately unhelpful.

Many authors share similar stories. While feedback is valuable, Reedsy’s attitude towards self-published authors can be disheartening. Instead of focusing on constructive criticism, they often seem more concerned with maintaining a certain image.

Don’t let this discourage you! Your story deserves to be heard. Seek feedback from beta readers who understand your genre and can provide genuine insights. Trust your instincts and remember, every great author was once unknown.

The Long Wait for Feedback

Many authors feel the excitement of finally finishing their manuscripts. It’s an exhilarating time, but that excitement can quickly turn into frustration, especially if you decide to use platforms like Reedsy Discovery. I can share my own story about this service, and I learned the hard way why it might be better to steer clear. For me, the process took months just to receive a review. It was incredibly disheartening to watch the calendar turn while I anxiously waited for feedback on my fantasy novel.

Rushed Reviews that Miss the Mark

When I finally got my review, I expected constructive feedback that would help improve my work. Instead, it felt like the reviewer barely skimmed the pages, and I was shocked by the negative comments. It felt like they rushed through the entire process, taking only a few days to write their review. This lack of thoroughness not only hurt my feelings as an author but left me confused. Was this reviewer even familiar with the fantasy genre? It seemed like they didn’t grasp the essence of what I was trying to convey in my book.

The Dismissive Attitude Towards Self-Published Authors

Upon reaching out to Reedsy about my concerns, I was met with a dismissive attitude. My inquiry about the reviewer’s background was brushed aside, and it became painfully clear that they look down on self-published authors. This sense of elitism isn’t just a personal feeling; many authors echo the same sentiments when they recount their experiences. A quick online search reveals countless stories of disappointment from authors who have felt the sting of rejection and scorn from those who are supposed to help them.

It’s crucial to understand that platforms like Reedsy are not the final gatekeepers of quality literature. They should not dictate the worth of our work. We have narratives that deserve to be told, and just because a review is negative doesn’t mean our stories lack value. In fact, many successful writers have encountered rejection or harsh critiques and still went on to achieve great things.

So, what can you do if you’re considering Reedsy or a similar service? Take your time. Research other authors’ experiences and seek alternatives. Sometimes, the opinions that matter most are those of your readers. Embrace feedback from beta readers who share your genre and perspective. They can help refine your manuscript before it reaches a wider audience.

In summary, while feedback is valuable, it’s essential to be selective about where you solicit it. Reedsy Discovery may not be the best choice for self-published authors seeking genuine guidance. Don’t let anyone dictate your worth as a storyteller. Trust your instincts and remember, every great author was once an unknown.

#selfpublishedauthor #writingtips #feedback #bookreview #reedsydiscovery #authorcommunity #writingcommunity #writersofinstagram